这里也存一份,几个记者对此事的看法,没有觉得需要重赛的
Here's what NBA analysts are saying about the controversy:
Michael McCann, Sports Illustrated
It’s very unlikely that Silver would unilaterally reverse the outcome of the Rockets-Spurs game. It’s unclear how the game would have ended if the Harden dunk had counted. After all, every play after the dunk would have been influenced in some way or another. The Rockets might have still won. To the extent the NBA takes action, a replay of the final 7:50 seems like a more reasonable approach than a reversal of the game’s outcome.
The harder question for Silver is whether he ought to order the replay. If he allows it here, does he open “Pandora’s Box” where he would be expected to do so again? Once Silver injects himself into a game to alter a referee’s mistake, other teams might demand he do so in future situations involving bad calls.
Brian T. Smith, Houston Chronicle
Harden’s should’ve-been dunk didn’t come in the final minute of regulation. Or the final seconds. Or the first or second OT. That, obviously, doesn’t make the inexcusable right. But the L should remain an L and, again, the Rockets are missing the much larger picture by acting like the refs and NBA wronged them.
The refs missed one call early in the fourth quarter. Harden and Westbrook missed 50 shots.
Jeff Balke, Houston Press
The pressure is mounting for leagues to show accountability in officiating or risk alienating fans.
This may have been a total fluke of a play — how often does a ball come out of the basket and mysteriously flip itself back up onto the rim? — but if not this, it will be something else in the future and the NBA needs to be prepared. Because, whatever they decide to do, what happened on Tuesday night cannot happen again. Not to any team.
Paul Pierce, ESPN's The Jump
The Rockets, they blew this game. I don't think you need to go back, look at it. I've seen blown calls on fouls, guys stepping out of bounds. [Kevin Durant] did this. He stepped clearly out of bounds. Never have I seen a blown call on a made basket... But that's human error.
Brian Windhorst, ESPN's The Jump
As far as I understand it, the only way you can replay a game is if the rules were misapplied. In this case, it was just a blown call. It was a particularly egregious blown call, you hate to see it, but it was a blown call. So I do not believe it will be replayed.
Shannon Sharpe, FS1's Undisputed
There is no way in hell they should play the final 7:50. There are goaltending's that happen in the first quarter or the second quarter or the third quarter that they miss. This was a missed call. The bottom line is the referees did not know the ball had gone in the basket. That was it.
Jalen Rose, ESPN's Jalen & Jacoby
The nets are too long. That's the adjustment, along with the rule change. As long as the refs are able to go back and say it's a two or a three after a play, they should be able to do it on a play like this.
这里也存一份,几个记者对此事的看法,没有觉得需要重赛的
Here's what NBA analysts are saying about the controversy:
Michael McCann, Sports Illustrated
It’s very unlikely that Silver would unilaterally reverse the outcome of the Rockets-Spurs game. It’s unclear how the game would have ended if the Harden dunk had counted. After all, every play after the dunk would have been influenced in some way or another. The Rockets might have still won. To the extent the NBA takes action, a replay of the final 7:50 seems like a more reasonable approach than a reversal of the game’s outcome.
The harder question for Silver is whether he ought to order the replay. If he allows it here, does he open “Pandora’s Box” where he would be expected to do so again? Once Silver injects himself into a game to alter a referee’s mistake, other teams might demand he do so in future situations involving bad calls.
Brian T. Smith, Houston Chronicle
Harden’s should’ve-been dunk didn’t come in the final minute of regulation. Or the final seconds. Or the first or second OT. That, obviously, doesn’t make the inexcusable right. But the L should remain an L and, again, the Rockets are missing the much larger picture by acting like the refs and NBA wronged them.
The refs missed one call early in the fourth quarter. Harden and Westbrook missed 50 shots.
Jeff Balke, Houston Press
The pressure is mounting for leagues to show accountability in officiating or risk alienating fans.
This may have been a total fluke of a play — how often does a ball come out of the basket and mysteriously flip itself back up onto the rim? — but if not this, it will be something else in the future and the NBA needs to be prepared. Because, whatever they decide to do, what happened on Tuesday night cannot happen again. Not to any team.
Paul Pierce, ESPN's The Jump
The Rockets, they blew this game. I don't think you need to go back, look at it. I've seen blown calls on fouls, guys stepping out of bounds. [Kevin Durant] did this. He stepped clearly out of bounds. Never have I seen a blown call on a made basket... But that's human error.
Brian Windhorst, ESPN's The Jump
As far as I understand it, the only way you can replay a game is if the rules were misapplied. In this case, it was just a blown call. It was a particularly egregious blown call, you hate to see it, but it was a blown call. So I do not believe it will be replayed.
Shannon Sharpe, FS1's Undisputed
There is no way in hell they should play the final 7:50. There are goaltending's that happen in the first quarter or the second quarter or the third quarter that they miss. This was a missed call. The bottom line is the referees did not know the ball had gone in the basket. That was it.
Jalen Rose, ESPN's Jalen & Jacoby
The nets are too long. That's the adjustment, along with the rule change. As long as the refs are able to go back and say it's a two or a three after a play, they should be able to do it on a play like this.